Skip to content
Executive search
Whether you're a church, school, nonprofit, or values-based business with a greater purpose, Vanderbloemen can help you hire the right executives to lead your organization.

A healthy staff review process does more than evaluate performance. It creates clarity, strengthens trust, and gives staff members a real path to grow — one that serves both the individual and the mission of the church.

For many churches, reviews feel awkward, overly administrative, or disconnected from actual ministry. Built with intention, though, they become one of the most valuable rhythms a church can develop. They help church leaders and staff understand what’s working, where growth is needed, and how each role connects to something larger.

Why Church Staff Reviews Matter

Staff reviews give churches a chance to pause, reflect, and realign. They move teams past assumptions and into honest conversations about performance, goals, and culture.

When done well, they strengthen accountability, surface opportunities for growth, and protect the health of the team. They also create a structure for coaching and development rather than waiting for problems to quietly compound.

What to Include in a Staff Review

A strong review measures more than completed tasks. It gives leaders a fuller picture of how a staff member is actually contributing.

Three areas carry the most weight.

Performance

Performance should be the most direct part of any review, but it only works when expectations have been clearly established. In many churches, job descriptions are too broad or vague to make fair evaluation possible.

Before reviewing performance, clarify responsibilities, priorities, and measurable outcomes. Consider:

  • What should this person accomplish daily, weekly, and quarterly?
  • Does the staff member understand the full scope of their role?
  • Are expectations specific enough to review objectively?

When responsibilities are well-defined, it becomes much easier to assess how well someone is carrying out the work entrusted to them.

Vision and Measurable Goals

A review should also examine whether a staff member’s goals connect to the church’s mission and direction. Individual goals don’t exist in isolation. They should tie to what the church is working toward as a whole.

If a major church goal is reaching more families in the community, each staff member’s goals should support that mission in some way. A children’s pastor might focus on engagement and curriculum. A communications leader might focus on outreach strategy. A ministry director might focus on team development.

Strong goals are:

  • Realistic
  • Specific
  • Measurable
  • Aligned with mission
  • Time-bound

When goals are clear, reviews become more meaningful. Leaders can evaluate not just activity, but impact.

Values and Culture

One of the most important parts of how to conduct a performance review at a church is assessing how a person lives out the organization’s values, not just how much they accomplish. This is what separates a culture-building review from a purely administrative one.

Values describe how a team works together and what kind of environment a church is trying to build. Reviewing staff through this lens helps leaders recognize not only what someone does, but how they do it.

Churches should ask:

  • Are our values clearly defined?
  • Does our team know them well?
  • Are they visible and regularly reinforced?
  • Do we recognize them in daily work?

When values are part of the review, the process becomes a tool for cultural health, not just performance management.

Strengthen Your Review Process

A thoughtful staff review can do more than evaluate performance. It can clarify expectations, reinforce your church’s mission, and create a healthier path for growth.

Contact Us Now

Six Steps to Run the Review

Once you know what you’re reviewing, the next step is building a process that’s fair, useful, and repeatable.

1. Develop the Questions

LifeChurch.tv’s 360-degree assessment uses nine leadership dimensions to evaluate staff members in a thorough and structured way. Each dimension includes a set of 4 to 9 questions designed to give a fuller picture of how a team member is contributing in their role.

The categories and the main question behind each one are:

  • Mission focus: How effectively does this person understand the team’s culture and make decisions that reflect the church’s goals?
  • Team development: How well does this individual coach direct reports and offer both encouragement and constructive correction?
  • Interpersonal relationships: How consistently does he or she show respect for others, regardless of position, and remain open to different perspectives?
  • Trustworthiness: Does this person own mistakes and keep commitments with integrity?
  • Drive for results: How well does this individual take initiative, address issues early, and motivate others to act?
  • Collaboration and teamwork: How effectively does this person manage expectations and work alongside others?
  • Team leadership: To what degree does this individual equip the team well and help foster a positive working environment?
  • Communication skills: Does he or she listen carefully and ask clarifying questions when needed?
  • Personal development: Does this individual receive feedback well and demonstrate a genuine willingness to grow?

2. Select the Survey Platform

Your team can choose from a variety of platforms depending on what fits your process best. If you want to explore additional options, our article highlights three other survey tools worth considering.

3. Send Out the Survey Request

Once the survey is ready, distribute a request form to the staff members who will participate. This step is more than a notification. It signals to everyone involved, both those giving and receiving feedback, that the process deserves serious attention. It also reinforces something worth saying plainly: leadership development is a vital part of how a church stays healthy.

4. Launch the Surveys

Once a staff member submits their review request, send the survey to the supervisor, peers, and direct reports listed on that form. The staff member should also complete the survey themselves, reflecting on their own performance as part of the process.

Give participants enough time to respond thoughtfully. Encourage them to be specific, constructive, and limited to behaviors they have personally observed. That keeps feedback fair, grounded, and genuinely useful.

5. Share the Feedback Report

When all responses are collected, provide each team member with a summary of their 360 results. The report should show how feedback from supervisors, peers, and direct reports compares, so the person receiving it can identify patterns more clearly.

A well-organized report gives staff members a fuller picture of how others experience their leadership and work style, and creates a useful starting point for reflection, discussion, and growth.

6. Self Analysis

After the feedback report has been shared, give staff members time to sit with what they’ve heard. LifeChurch.tv’s 360 self-analysis report includes several categories to help each person process the results with intention.

These categories include:

  • Overall impressions: How did the results compare with what you expected?
  • Your respondents: How many people did you invite to participate, how many responded, and what might explain the difference?
  • Comparison to fellow church leaders: How do your scores compare across the leadership areas assessed?
  • Individual behavior ratings: What is the main message in each category, and how does it show up in daily work?
  • Highest and lowest scored items: What do these results suggest about how others perceive you?
  • Development plan: What two growth strategies will you commit to over the next three months in both your strongest and weakest areas?

These reflection points turn feedback into a real development conversation rather than a one-time evaluation.

Make the Process Ongoing

Church staff reviews shouldn’t happen once a year and disappear. Healthy teams benefit from regular feedback throughout the year, especially when goals are broken into smaller, achievable steps.

More frequent check-ins reduce anxiety, keep people aligned, and make coaching feel like part of the culture rather than an event. They also help leaders address issues earlier and celebrate wins more consistently. For many churches, a rhythm of quarterly or 60-day check-ins creates a more sustainable environment for growth.

Why This Matters for the Whole Church

A thoughtful staff review process strengthens more than individual employees. It strengthens the entire church.

When leaders communicate clearly, staff feel genuinely supported, and values are reinforced across the team, the whole organization becomes healthier. People understand what’s expected, where they’re growing, and how their work ties into the mission.

That kind of environment doesn’t emerge on its own. It’s built through intentional leadership, honest communication, and a review process that holds both excellence and care in equal regard.

Final Thought

If your church wants to build a stronger staff review process, start with clarity. Define what matters, ask better questions, and create a rhythm that supports growth over time.

When reviews are rooted in performance, mission, and values, they can become one of the most important tools for strengthening your team and your church.

Advance Your Mission

Ready to go farther faster?

Contact Us

Advance Your Mission

Time to find your new calling?

Find a Job